ok i have been "advised" to place this on here by Oldhat to get your feedback and start generating a barrel of hateful spite and bile to power Super Si Spurrier's future endeavours....
Essentially, it looks at the boring, dull and overtly earnest rock and pop acts whose heads we would like to stove in with a rusty shovel. If you don't fancy reading it, the list is...
James Taylor The Eagles Sting Hall and Oates Coldplay Matchbox 20 Hootie and the Blowfish Phil Collins Huey Lewis and the News Bryan Adams
but we know this list of musical gruel and tofu is not complete. WHO else should be on this list... and why??
I say this as a full-on fan of their music, but Metallica. They've been trying way too fucking hard for the past decade or so, but Some Kind of Monster really hammered home how completely not-cool they are now. (That said I really like about 2/3 of Death Magnetic and I'm really looking forward to the new album.)
remember we are talking about the squarest, not necessarily the one with the most boring music.
Example - Bryan Adams. He does do a LOT of charity work, but he is a strict vegan and is teetotoal. the militancy of that teetotalism came into force when he moved to London, nearby a local pub. He didn't like the rowdiness of said pub, so he bought it... so he could shut it down and make his house bigger...
Maroon 5 The Strokes Dave Matthews Train Creed Jack Johnson James Blunt David Gray Jason Mraz Fallout Boy The Killers
This is probably all old stuff that isn't on the radio anymore, but it was all big when I used to work in places that played it nonstop. I feel sick at the memory.
I think the rule is, once you've gotten more than a consecutive hour of airtime on a Cumulus radio station, and this happens less than ten years after the formation of your band, you're pretty much doomed.
Which is too bad, really - every time the radio comes on (usually while I'm switching CDs) and I hear a song I like, I have to frown and go "oh, man, I'm gonna be sick of that in two months."
Then again, this rule isn't universal. I'm kind of glad that I can still say the name Janelle Monae or The Hush Sound and still have people give me a "huh?" look.
In regards to Metallica - considering how long they've been around, I'm amazed they're still together and making music. A lot of it's hit or miss, but the glory of the download age is that I can ignore the misses and just nab the hits - I only own three songs off Death Magnetic, but I played the fuck out of those three songs for about six weeks after I got them.
Man, Korn... I remember when I was a kid, and liking a song called "Freak on a Leash" made me a sex-maniac weirdo as far as all the other kids at school were concerned. I'll always love them for that.
Manic Street Preachers - burst onto the scene all dress-wearing and eyeliner and arm-cutting, quickly to turn in yet another MOR stadium rock outfit. Tho I doubt I've knowingly heard anything of theirs since the 90's.