Not signed in (Sign In)
  1.  (9083.1)
    Rather than starting a new thread every month for this list of the Top 300 comics and graphic novels sold through Diamond Comics Distributors, I'll just refresh it every month when I've got the latest list done and ready for viewing.

    Here's Septembers non Marvel/DC Top 300 list.
    http://www.renderwrx.net/comicsales.htm

    If you scroll down you'll find the previous months listings.
  2.  (9083.2)
    Renderwrx.net now has October's sales lists up.
    http://www.renderwrx.net/comicsales.htm

    These lists contain no Marvel or DC numbers, and while none of the non big two books sell numbers like Marvel & DC, the numbers overall don't look to bad to me on average. Obviously nobody's getting rich, but the wealth and dirth of material looks good considering this is Diamond and the direct market.

    But Stan Lee and Boom Studio's have to be terribly disappointed. 12,000 copies for their heavily marketed Soldier Zero comic. Ouch!
    • CommentAuthorepalicki
    • CommentTimeNov 11th 2010 edited
     (9083.3)
    But Stan Lee and Boom Studio's have to be terribly disappointed. 12,000 copies for their heavily marketed Soldier Zero comic. Ouch!


    Um, that chart puts their sales at almost 20,000 copies, and reorders put that number at about 24K if BOOM's press release is to be believed, making it their most successful launch to date. Granted, I don't know what kind of a page rate the creators involved are making, or what Stan's cut might be, but most Image creators would kill a nun for those numbers.

    Here's the Newsarama piece on the book's success: http://www.newsarama.com/comics/soldier-zero-best-selling-boom-title-101026.html
  3.  (9083.4)
    Whoops I meant 20,000 in my first post. But with such a heavily marketed line and Stan Lee's name on it, I think they woulda expected more. Like in the 50-75,000 range.

    Hell, Kevin Smiths Green Hornet debuted with better sales than this.
    • CommentAuthorepalicki
    • CommentTimeNov 12th 2010
     (9083.5)
    Johanna over at Comics Worth Reading has this very interesting analysis of Soldier Zero's "success."

    But, frankly, I don't know that Lee's name attached to anything is really much of a selling point these days -- (I bought -- and enjoyed -- Soldier Zero because Cornell's the guy doing the heavy lifting, much like I'll be buying Traveler because it's Waid behind the wheel) -- whereas Kevin Smith's name attached to a comic actually draws potential readers/customers from outside comics' customary readership.
  4.  (9083.6)
    Yeah I read that article over at Johanna Draper Carlsons blog (a great blog by the way), and I guess you are right, who does a guy like Stan Lee appeal to nowadays anyways? I guess it would be another thing if he was actually writing the stories themselves, maybe then 50,000 + copies sold would be a probability?

    But I love that there are so many "indy" comics slowly matriculating up the charts (especially graphic novels), but the days of anyone getting fat and rich off comics is definitely over right?
    • CommentAuthorSpike3185
    • CommentTimeNov 13th 2010
     (9083.7)
    I'm thinkin the days of anyone new getting into the field and making any kind of livable income are largely over until the whole dead tree/digital thing calms down a little bit. We'll see what happens after that. This is, of course, aside from a few geniuses who find a new way to break in or just have undeniable talent and go straight from Deviantart to DC Comics.
    • CommentAuthorepalicki
    • CommentTimeNov 16th 2010
     (9083.8)
    the days of anyone getting fat and rich off comics is definitely over right?


    I dunno about "fat and rich," but Kirkman seems to be doing okay. Besides, you've got long odds against becoming "fat and rich" in any job, in any industry, though, don't you?

    Consider also how quickly Jason Aaron*, Jonathan Hickman and Nick Spencer went from their first published comics to regular work (and in the case of Aaron and Hickman, exclusive contracts) at one of the Big Two.

    Like Spike said, there will always be a place for people with talent and determination.

    (*I know, I know. I'm dismissing that Wolverine contest entry as, if not a fluke, then an outlier, at least.)
  5.  (9083.9)
    Novembers Alt/Indy sales lists are now up.

    http://forums.comicbookresources.com/forumdisplay.php?f=20

    Hey look at that! The new Vampirella debuts with good sales. Anybody read it? More of the same, or something actually worthwhile?
  6.  (9083.10)
    December's Indy comics & graphic novels sales lists courtesy of Diamond Comics Distributors are now available here
    http://www.renderwrx.net/comicindustrysales.htm

    There's a lot of bad things to say about a monopoly, but at least they publish their sales lists. I try to get sales lists from the other distributors and they ignore me.
  7.  (9083.11)
    @Paul: I'm hardly an unbiased opinion, but critical response to my Vampi debut was largely favorable with a few naysayers pissed off that I've temporarily done away with the spacethong. I'm told the traditional issue 2 plummet was followed by a strong rebound with issue 3, so I'm starting to breathe a cautious sigh of relief about Vampirella.

    -E
  8.  (9083.12)
    All the luck on Vampirella Eric, I'm sure its a tough gig despite the historical standing of the character.
    How many issues have they guaranteed you or you can't really say?
  9.  (9083.13)
    I'm on for six, with an option to renew for a bunch more; just finished writing issue 7 (a done-in-one), and moving on to the next arc, so I guess I'm on for at least 12, possibly 16 issues.

    Until that changes, of course. :P

    -E
  10.  (9083.14)
    January's Sales Lists are now up. Interesting stuff once again. With all the recent controversy surrounding Eric Powell and his outrageous video, his latest trade of Goon shows up at #4 on the Diamond list. Awesome.

    http://www.renderwrx.net/comicindustrysales.htm
  11.  (9083.15)
    February Sales lists are up http://www.renderwrx.net/comicindustrysales.htm


    Here's an excerpt. These are the highest "Indy" placers on the overall top 300 sales lists.
    excerpt

    Sales be down.
  12.  (9083.16)
    March Indy Sales Lists are now up.
    http://www.renderwrx.net/comicindustrysales.htm

    Sales are down across the board, except for Walking Dead which is still selling through.

    What a title, eh?

    Check out the full list for comics & graphic novels (non marvel/DC).